
Max sidled up to me at dinner and pulled my head toward him with both hands. “I’m gonna tell you a secret,” he said in the barely audible sub-whisper he likes to play with.
“What?” I whispered back.
“I’m not going to tell you about your birthday,” he said, and he walked away. I waved at my ear to dust off the garlic bread crumbs.
Forty minutes later, he did it again – pulled me close and wheezed into my ear. “Don’t look under Mia’s bookshelf, because that’s a secret,” he said, conspiratorially.
This time, he was not wearing pants.

I was sorting mail in the kitchen when Mia and Sarah snuck into the living room and started whispering at each other. After a few moments, Mia emerged to ask me my favorite cake flavor and shape. She was doing a survey — she wanted to ask everyone in the house, and then make the kind of cake that had the most votes.
I didn’t hear her ask anyone else.

By bedtime, Max had dropped the whisper entirely.
“Daddy, I’m gonna tell you something,” he said, nowhere near sleep.
“What’s that?”
“Daddy, don’t look under Mia’s bookshelf.”
“I won’t, Max.”
“Because that’s a secret.”
“Okay, I won’t look under—”
“If you go into Mia’s bedroom don’t look under the bookshelf because that’s a secret and it’s for your birthday.”
“Okay,” I said, and I gave him a solemn nod.
And he pulled my face close and pressed his nose against mine. And said nothing more.








